“…restoring the fit between the world that is and the world that should be…”
from Parkes, CM. Bereavement. Mortality: Virtual Themed Issue 2003.
KEYPOINTS
- Loss is a common human experience. How people experience loss varies tremendously.
- Grief is a natural response to loss and there are no right or wrong ways for expressing grief
- Grief can be experienced psychologically, behaviorally, socially and/or physically
- Grief can be experienced in losses that are not always associated with death
- Grief involves people finding ways to adapt and cope with change, explore meaning in their loss, and find ways to have a continued bond with the deceased
- Emotions, expressions, and understandings of grief are specific to the person, and their relationship to their social, cultural and spiritual world
- Rituals, customs and mourning practices have enormous spiritual, social, and personal significance for the dying and the survivors
- Secondary stressors and life circumstances are risk factors that impact processing and adjustment to loss and death
- Distress and positive emotions are possible at the same time
- Stressful and difficult caregiving situations can impact grief and bereavement
CONSIDERATIONS
Supporting people through their losses, grief and bereavement involves attending to a wide range of possible experiences and contributing factors.
Language of Loss
Grief
- Personal feelings, emotions and reactions to loss
Bereavement
- The state of having experienced a death and the process of integrating the death into one’s life
Mourning
- The private and public rituals, customs, practices and processes to loss
Anticipated grief
- Grief or distressing experiences that may occur when a patient or family/caregiver is expecting a future change, loss or death
Difficult grief
- May be influenced when there are multiple and/or concurrent losses and deaths – survival issues take priority
- May occur when the loss or death is not recognized, valued or accepted in the family and/or community of the bereaved
- May occur when specific social and cultural responses to grief are either intensified or suppressed
- Sudden or unexpected death of patient or other person
Secondary losses
- Other past, present, or future losses and experiences that have happened or may happen as a result of illness and death (e.g., loss of income, faith, support, identity and roles, social connections, personal relationships intimacy, home and other material resources)
Language of Grief
Grief can involve a combination of feelings, emotions, reactions and behaviours. Sometimes, these may seem to conflict with one another. This is a natural and normal part of processing, adjusting, and making meaning to the loss or anticipated losses. They are culturally and socially influenced.
Some examples include:
Physical
- Symptoms of shock
- Tightness in chest
- Shortness of breath
- Weakness, restlessness, lack of energy
- Disruption to sleeping and eating patterns
- Emptiness
Emotional
- Numb, empty
- Anger
- Sadness, crying or wailing,
- Helplessness, hopelessness, fear
- Guilt, relief
- Despair, feeling lost
- Calm
- Overwhelmed
- Abandoned
- Free
- Anxious
- Frustration, powerlessness
- Conflicting emotions
Cognitive
- Confusion, poor concentration
- Self-blame
- Disbelief
- Forgetfulness, problems with short term memory
- Pre-occupation with thoughts of the deceased
- Acceptance
- Lost sense of purpose
- Shift in perspectives
Behavioural
- Isolation, embarrassment, social withdrawal
- Need for information or understanding from different sources
- Pre-occupation with other tasks and responsibilities
- Verbal expression of anger, silence, dissociation
Spiritual
- Blame
- Exploring hope and purpose
- Wanting to die or join the deceased
- Loss or strengthening of beliefs
- Exploring continuing relationship with the deceased
Factors Impacting Grief and Bereavement
Personal
- Coping skills
- Circumstances of the illness and death
- Involvement in the care of the deceased
- Illness beliefs
- Unresolved/concurrent losses
- Addiction or mental health issues
Interpersonal
- Relationship with person who died
- Family dynamics
- Gender, social and cultural expectations
- Roles and responsibilities within family and community systems
- Availability of cultural and/or language support
- Competing and/or current stressors (e.g., other caregiving responsibilities, own illness, etc.)
Socio-economic
- Access to immediate and on-going social support
- Access to financial resources, stable living arrangements, employment
Cultural and spiritual
- Access and availability of spiritual and cultural support systems
- Access to traditional healing practices
- Ability to conduct/participate in rituals, customs and mourning practices
- Loss of meaning or faith
STRATEGIES
Grief and loss is experienced not only after the death of a loved one (bereavement) but can occur throughout the illness continuum. The following questions may be helpful during conversations with patients and family/caregivers to better understand and support their grief, loss, and bereavement experiences:
- “What stresses or changes are you experiencing at this time (e.g., illness changes, difficulties coping, other life stresses)?"
- “How are you feeling physically? What are you noticing?”
- “What kinds of thoughts and feelings have you been experiencing recently?”
- “How are you coping with your thoughts and feelings? Is there anything about your thoughts and feelings that you are concerned or worried about? What do you find helpful?”
- “Who do you share your thoughts and feelings with? How do you share your thoughts and feelings with …? How do you support each other?
- “Tell me about how you are managing with all of your other responsibilities, aside from caregiving for your loved one (e.g., family, employment, community responsibilities)?"
- “Tell me about any important decisions that you are making, or are finding challenging to make?”
- “What are your family, spiritual, and/or cultural traditions that are important for the health care team to know?”
- “How are you finding ways to take care of your self (physically, emotionally, spiritually) during this time?”
- “How can we support you? What would be most helpful during this time”
- "What other types of support might you find helpful (e.g., spiritual support, community organizations, mental health professional, volunteer, etc.)?"
SOURCES/REFERENCES
- Bruera E, De Lima L, Wenk R, Farr W, editors. Palliative care in the developing world: principles and practice. 1st ed. Houston (TX): International Association for Hospice and Palliative Care; 2004.
- Cairns M, Thompson M, Wainwright W. Transitions in dying and bereavement: a psychosocial guide for hospice and palliative Care. Victoria (BC): Victoria Hospice Society; 2003.
- Doka K, Davidson J, editors. Living with grief: who we are, how we grieve. Hospice Foundation of America; 1998.
- Downing GM, Wainwright W, editors. Medical care of the dying. 4th ed. Victoria (BC): Victoria Hospice Society; 2006.
- Kumar S. Grieving mindfully. California: New Harbour; 2005.
- Librach L, Gifford-Jones W. Ian Anderson continuing education program in end-of-life care. Module 13: grief and bereavement. [Online]. Available from: URL:http://www.cme.utoronto.ca/ENDOFLIFE/Modules/GRIEF%20AND%20BEREAVEMENT%20MODULE.pdf
- Oliviere D, Monroe B, editors. Death, dying, and social differences. New York: Oxford University Press; 2004.
- Parkes, CM. Bereavement. Mortality: Virtual Themed Issue 2003. [Online]: Available from: URL:http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals/archive/bereave.pdf
- Parkes C, Laungani P, Young B, editors. Death and bereavement across cultures. London: Routledge; 1997.
- Stroebe M, Schut H. The dual process model of coping with bereavement: rationale and description. Death Stud 1999;23(3):197-224. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10848151
- Klass D, Silverman P, Nickman S, editors. Continuing bonds: new understanding of grief. Washington: Taylor and Francis; 1996.
